FROM: HOLLEY CARNRIGHT
DATE: JULY 29, 2019
RE: PRESS RELEASE - ULSTER
COUNTY JURY CONVICTS KINGSTON MAN OF MURDER, ROBBERY AND GUN POSSESSION
An Ulster County trial jury of 8 men and 4 women deliberated for
about 4 hours last Friday and returned a verdict convicting 39 year old Maurice
Stansberry, Sr., of 27 Washington Avenue, Kingston, for the murder of Mark
Lancaster. Stansberry Sr. shot and killed Lancaster on Sawkill Road on December
1, 2018 following an armed robbery.
Minutes before the murder, Stansberry, his son Maurice
Stansberry Jr., and a third individual, Kevin Gardener, had gone to the Sawkill
Trailer Park for a marijuana deal which had been set up by Gardener. Stansberry
Sr. was armed with a loaded nine millimeter pistol. When he was shown the pot he
pointed the loaded gun at the pot dealer, the victim’s son, and demanded the
pot. He and Gardener then ran back to
their waiting get-away car driven by Stansberry Jr. and fled.
When Lancaster learned that his son had been robbed he chased the
Stansberry car about a mile and a half on Sawkill Road heading towards
Washington Avenue and pulled in front of the vehicle causing it to stop. As
Lancaster got out of his car Stansberry Sr. pulled out the pistol, racked it,
and announced that “I’m going to shoot one of these motherfuckers.” Lancaster,
who was unarmed, opened the driver’s door of the Stansberry car and demanded that
they give back his property. Stansberry Sr. then shot him in the lower abdomen.
The bullet passed through him severing major blood vessels, causing severe
internal bleeding and hemorrhage resulting in Lancaster’s death.
Maurice Stansberry Sr., Maurice Stansberry Jr., and Kevin
Gardener were indicted by an Ulster County Grand Jury for felony Murder,
Robbery, and Weapons charges. Felony Murder is defined as a murder committed
during the commission of or immediate flight from certain felonies, armed
robbery being one of them. Felony murder extends criminal liability to all of
the parties knowingly involved in the underlying felony.
Stansberry Sr.’s trial began last Monday and ended Friday with a
verdict convicting him for Murder, 4 counts of Armed Robbery, Criminal
Possession of a Weapon in the 2nd degree, and Criminal Use of a
Firearm in the 1st degree. The murder conviction carries a maximum
prison sentence of up to 25 years to life. His sentencing is set for October 4.
Stansberry Sr. has multiple misdemeanor convictions dating back
over 20 years as well as a prior felony conviction for Criminal Sale of a
Controlled Substance, third degree. He is believed to be a member of the Bloods
Street Gang.
Prior to the Stansberry trial, Kevin Gardener pleaded guilty to
felony murder and removed himself from the trial of the case. He is expected to
be sentenced October 1 in Ulster County Court. Maurice Stansberry Jr.
cooperated with the DA’s Office in exchange for a negotiated plea and sentence
recommendation; the disposition of his case is expected later this Fall.
Stansberry Sr. was represented by Russell Schindler of the
Public Defender’s Office. The case was prosecuted by Assistant District Attorneys
Emmanuel Nneji and Timothy Lawson.
